Ayna and Leslie both simplified the expression. Which student is correct
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/204e4/204e42fa5764d48382943a179348c5c22b3cefb6" alt="Ayna and Leslie both simplified the expression Which student is correct class="
Given:
[tex]\sqrt[]{18x^4y^5}[/tex]The expansion is,
[tex]\sqrt[]{18x^4y^5}=\sqrt[]{2\times3\times3\times x\times x\times x\times x\times y\times y\times y\times y\times y}[/tex]On simplification we get,
[tex]\begin{gathered} =\sqrt[]{2\times3^2\times x^2\times x^2\times y^2\times y^2\times y} \\ =3x^2y^2\sqrt[]{2y} \end{gathered}[/tex]Hence, Leslie was correct.